REVIEW: A Match for Mary Bennet by Eucharista Ward


A Match for Mary Bennet by Eucharista Ward Review by A Baja Janeite

Mary Bennet is quite satisfied. Now that Lizzy and Jane have married wealthy men, Mary can ignore her mother’s schemes to find Mary a husband. She can withdraw into her music and books. She no longer has to worry about her fate when Longbourn is invaded by the Collins’ family. She need never marry. Well, at least that is what Mary hopes…

Two very different men become part of Mary’s life.

Stephen Oliver, gentle and intuitive, glories in his vocation as a minister. He asks Mary to help him, but she is not sure that she even likes him. Kitty likes him, but would she make a proper clergyman’s wife?

Dashing and wealthy, James Stilton begs Mary to be his wife. What is his motive? Is it love or something else?

Advertised as an “inspirational Pride and Prejudice sequel,” A Match for Mary Bennet centers on the third Bennet sister. Eucharista Ward lovingly develops Mary’s character from the reflective pedant encountered in P&P to a wiser, independent woman. Lizzy, Jane and their husbands are now minor characters, but we follow their growing families and tragedies as these events touch Mary’s life. Ward introduces a neighborhood kleptomaniac and fortune hunters who add humor and tension to the plot.

A Match for Mary Bennet is written in a narrative style similar to P&P, although the author sometimes uses a stream of consciousness technique. To my delight, the author alludes to P&P incidents and dialogue at very apt times. She mentions titles of music and books popular during the Regency period. My only criticisms are that the book is a slow read at times, and Lizzy is not the same. Mrs. Bennet, Mr. Collins, Lydia and many others, however, remain true to character and amuse and irritate us in turn. Overall, I enjoyed this novel very much.

What makes this sequel “inspirational”? Marriage and integrity are honored. Sex is alluded to as a pleasurable, even fun, benefit of marriage. Church attendance is expected. These are values consistent with Jane Austen’s novels. Perhaps, the most inspirational part is the author herself. A Sylvania Franciscan nun, Eucharista Ward retired from teaching high school English and now works as a nurse’s aide for an assisted living program. She wrote this book while working night shift, caring for other retired sisters. Now, that is truly inspiring!

Additional note: Don’t miss the mention of Uncle Phillip’s law clerk at the end of the book- not quite what James Edward Austen-Leigh’s book prophesied!

8 thoughts on “REVIEW: A Match for Mary Bennet by Eucharista Ward

  1. rae

    I am usually on top of most of the P&P paraliterature/fanfiction, but had not heard of this book. Sounds good. But in what way is Lizzy not Lizzy? You have intrigued me and if she is far different from the Lizzy we know and love from Ms. Austen, then I won’t be in a terrific hurry to track this book down. I must have Lizzy and Darcy true to canon, if only in essentials 🙂


  2. Baja Janeite

    Good question! Lizzy is a minor character who is used to show the joy of marrying for love. At the beginning, Mary has the misconception that Lizzy married Darcy solely to give security to the Bennet family. (Mary is relieved because she does not want to marry.) However, Mary observes Lizzy and Darcy together throughout the book and begins to value their devotion to each other.

    Lizzy is a nice character in the book, but she just does not “sparkle” as she does in P&P. She makes no witty comments (that I remember) nor does she observe the weaknesses in other characters.

    Of course, the focus is Mary’s character development, not Lizzy’s. In truth, this really did not affect my enjoyment of the book.


  3. Oh my. One of my TBR Top Prio. List.

    Since Mary Bennet was just a minor character on P&P plus she was not as outstanding as her other sisters were, this book might give us a fresh theme since other Austen inspired books centers mostly on Darcy, Lizzy, Darcy and Lizzy. 😐

    Thanks on the review.


  4. Meghan Belle

    My little cradle Catholic heart is tickled that a nun wrote this sequel. 😀 Looking forward to reading it. Thanks for the review.


  5. Dorothy McHenry

    Thanks for the review.I’m looking forward to buying and reading the book. Eucharista Ward is described as a “Sylvania Fransiscan nun”. Does Sylvania refer to a place? In Ohio perhaps?


  6. Baja Janeite

    Yes, Dorothy, it refers to Sylvania, Ohio, where a group of Franciscan sisters from Minnesota started a new “province” in 1917. You can read a little of their history at

    (I had to research this when I wrote the review- to verify that I should use “Sylvania” and not “Sylvanian” before the words “Franciscan nun”.)


Comments are closed.